Saturday, March 19, 2011

Mr Rogers versus Sesame Street

My issue with so many of these models is that I cannot start to visualize them from reading the articles or listening to the lecture. I start to have a cursory understanding though when I look at the examples. Usually when I see the examples the light bulbs go off and it starts to come together. But with Anchored Instruction, even when I saw the examples, I still could not get my head around it. It reminded me slightly of what it was like to watch Mister Rogers compared to what it was like to watch Sesame Street. The examples shown demonstrating this model, seem much more like Mr. Roger's in comparison to other models we have been seeing. Like other models we have discussed this seems to be much more geared towards elementary education. I could sees the value in using this model with students who can overstimulated if there too many audio or visual cues to process. Again, there was always something very calming about watching Mr. Rogers and that element popped out at me when I looked at these examples. Simple and easy to process. One tool though that I could see using with Anchored Instruction is Prezi. Prezi allows you to create a presentation where the viewer can move around at will. It would make it more Sesame Street than Mr. Rogers in that it would allow for more non-linear approach. Still, I am not sure when and if I would use this model with the students or participants I work with.

2 comments:

Julie said...

What an interesting comparison between Mr. Rogers and Sesame Street!

I agree that this model seemed more "Simple and easy to process." As a young student, I liked having a more narrowed focus/end goal that I was trying to meet/work toward. The testing and problem solving along the way in this model allows for calculated small steps toward the finish line (sort of reminds me of the marathon that I did in the fall... "one step at a time...").

I'm not sure that the creation of this model would be so "simple and easy," but could be very effective.

(Julie Jones)

Barb Browning said...

Julie - I agree so much about the need to have a "narrowed focus/end goal". I can get overwhelmed these days when there is so much to process. There is something calming and reassuring about having those small steps that one can cross off on the way to the larger goal. I love making lists for this very reason. In looking ahead, I like this aspect of the Star Legacy model for the same reason, it breaks it down into definable stages that a student works through.

I also agree with your statement that creating this design may not be simple but if the end result is that it is a process that students can process and engage with then it is worth it.

THANKS!
Barb